Recently I was listening to a podcast of popular Christian apologist Ravi Zacharias. He brought to my attention a quote from a letter Susanna Wesley wrote to her son John Wesley when he asked her what the considered sin to be.
"Take this rule: whatever weakens your reason, impairs the tenderness of your conscience, obscures your sense of God, or takes off your relish of spiritual things; in short, whatever increases the strength and authority of your body over your mind, that thing is sin to you, however innocent it may be in itself."Now, Susanna Wesley is certainly entitled to her opinion. After all, that's what Christianity is about isn't it... our opinion of what the scripture is telling us? If you attend bible study in many churches today you might be inclined to think that. And opinions are fine... for what they are... opinions. However, at some point you have to put aside opinion and look into the scripture. Then, at this point there might be room for some interpretation (but if you're going to go into that you need to spend time with the original Greek/Hebrew) but by and large the scripture is pretty much black and white (and red and white depending on your translation).
So lets look at this piece of advice Susanna gave her son and consider the scriptural relevance. James addresses this thought very well. In chapter three of the book of James he addresses the tongue... how double-edged it can be (v. 10). Then he says "...this should not be" (Ouch)! The rest of chapters three and four explain to us how our lives are driven from the inside... from our hearts. If our hearts are on the things of this earth then our lives (and our tongues) will be likewise motivated. In other words what we say (and how we say it) is pretty much what we are on the inside.
What James is communicating in these chapters is that every aspect of a Christian's life should be based on and come out from our submission to and our love for Christ. And he gets a bit more personal than that. He says that "friendship with the world is hatred toward God" (4:4). What does that mean? It means that putting on our "Jesus clothes" on Sunday morning for church and then hanging them up for the rest of the week is giving us exactly what we want... the appearance of Christanity without the substance (or without the effort). It means that studying your bible for two hours a week and then looking at twenty hours a week of trash on television or the internet is doing absolutely nothing for our relationship with Christ. In fact he says it's hatred (or hostility) toward God. He even covers the heart in these matters in 4:3 when he says when we do ask we don't receive because our motives aren't pure. Why are our motives not pure? Because we are a friend to the world... and not to God (Ouch again).
Basically, we need to get real with our relationship with Christ. If we want to be like Christ we need to be surrendered to Christ... completely.
Lastly, James leaves us with a serious challenge. In 4:17 (NIV) he says "anyone, then, who knows the good he ought to do and doesn't do it, sins" . Other translations say, "to him it is sin". This makes it personal. We can't point our fingers at anyone else now because James has shown us that the life we live is all up to us. We either fully submit to Christ or we don't. We're either a friend of God or we're hostile toward God.
Now, go back and read again the answer Susanna Wesley gave her son. Then ask yourself, "what is sin to me"?